Lillys Super Subs Menu

Phone Ahead Call - (352) 343-GOOD (4663)

Printable Menu

HOT SUBS

  • Lilly's Philly Cheesesteak

    100% Choice flanked beef grilled with just the right amount of onion, our own tomato sauce, pickles and provolone or american cheese.

    Large 12" - $8.49... Small 8" - $6.99
  • Mushroom Cheesesteak

    Flank steak Grilled up with onions, sweet bell peppers and mushrooms. Covered with cheese, sauce and pickles. They're Great!

    Large 12" - $8.49... Small 8" - $6.99
  • Owners Choice Add On

    Get'er Done with BOTH American and Provolone Cheese

    Large - 0.50... Small - 0.33
  • California Cheesesteak

    100% choice flanked beef on a healthy bed of lettuce, tomatoes, grilled onions, pickles and mayo. Plus our signature tomato sauce and cheese. You'll Enjoy It Fore Sure!

    Large 12" - $8.49... Small 8" - $6.99
  • Meatball Italiano (or Teriyaki)

    Italian meatballs, grilled onions, our own tomato sauce and smothered with provolone and parmesan cheese.

    Large 12" - $6.54... Small 8" - $5.60
  • Meatball Parmesan

    Large 12" - $5.97 Small 8" - $4.87
  • Sausage & Cheese

    Tasty Italian sausage served with grilled onions and sweet bell peppers. Our tomato sauce, provolone cheese and parmesan cheese adds just that perfect touch.

    Large 12" - $6.96... Small 8" - $5.84
  • Grilled Roast Beef & Cheese

    Healthy portions of lean roast beef grilled just right with melted cheese piled on a bed of lettuce, onions, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Roast Beef Italiano

    Grilled onions, tomato sauce, provolone and parmesan cheese.

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Grilled Ham & Cheese

    Plenty of imported ham and melted cheese on a bed of lettuce, onions, tomatoes, mayo and pickles.

    Large 12" - $6.96... Small 8" - $5.84
  • Grilled Turkey & Cheese

    Plenty of fresh turkey and melted cheese on a bed of lettuce, onions, tomatoes, mayo and pickles.

    Large 12" - $7.47... Small 8" - $6.16
  • Monti-Christo

    Tender white turkey, grilled imported ham, bacon, choice of cheese melted to perfection, all resting on a bed of mayo, lettuce, onions, tomatoes and pickles.

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Lilly's Gizmo

    Mayo, lettuce, onions, tomatoes & pickles, topped with hamburger patties, grilled ham & melted cheese. It’s a real meal.

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu

    Grilled ham & swiss on white meat breasts with lettuce, tomatoes and honey mustard dressing.

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    Our yummy chicken fillets resting on mayo, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, pickles.

    Large 12" - $7.66... Small 8" - $6.44
  • Chicken-Bacon-Ranch

    Or try it with Bar-B-Que sauce instead!

    Large 12" - $7.99... Small 8" - $6.77
  • Chicken Italiano

    Grilled onions, provolone, parmesan and our tomato sauce cover this bird.

    Large 12" - $7.66 Small 8" - $6.44

COLD SUBS

ALL COLD SUBS HAVE LETTUCE, TOMATOES AND ONIONS UNLESS YOU SAY “HOLD IT.”

  • Lilly's COMBO

    Cooked salami, hard salami, mortadella, imported ham, provolone cheese, topped off with oregano, oil and vinegar. Our MOST POPULAR cold treat.

    Large 12" - $7.78... Small 8" - $5.98
  • Italian Special

    Same as our Italian but a layer of capicola ham is added. Capicola is a spicy flavored ham cured with red pepper and anise seed. It adds a delicious flavor! Give it a try!

    Large 12" - $7.78... Small 8" - $5.98
  • Italian

    Dual layers of cooked salami, hard salami, and provolone cheese.

    Large 12" - $7.19... Small 8" - $5.84
  • Genoa

    Triple layer of hard salami with provolone cheese, lettuce, onions and tomatoes. Seasoned with oil, vinegar & oregano.

    Large 12" - $6.77... Small 8" - $5.60
  • Tuna & Cheese

    Made fresh every morning with hefty portions of tuna, the finest quality around.

    Large 12" - $6.77... Small 8" - $5.60
  • Turkey & Cheese

    Healthy & tasty oven roasted white turkey breast on a bed of mayo, lettuce,onions, tomatoes and pickles.

    Large 12" - $7.38... Small 8" - $5.98
  • Ham & Cheese

    Plenty of thinly sliced imported ham with mayo, lettuce, onions, tomatoes and pickles. All American favorite.

    Large 12" - $6.77... Small 8" - $5.60
  • Roast Beef & Cheese

    Plenty of choice lean beef piled high on a bed of mayo, lettuce, onions, tomatoes and pickles.

    Large 12" - $7.66... Small 8" - $6.44
  • All American Combo

    Ham, turkey and roast beef with American cheese and all the fixin’s.

    Large 12" - $7.66... Small 8" - $6.44
  • Vegetarian

    For those who don’t want meat. 3 layers of american, provolone and swiss cheese with all the toppings. Try it with mayo or oil & vinegar dressing.

    Large 12" - $5.84... Small 8" - $4.90
  • Garden Sub

    No fat & good for you! 8 veggies piled high to take care of your hunger.

    Large 12" - $5.84... Small 8" - $4.90
  • Lilly's Ultimate Hoagie

    Everything but the sink! Cooked and hard salami, mortadella, turkey, roast beef, imported ham, provolone & american cheese, plus all the fixins. What a meal!

    Large 12" - $8.97... Small 8" - $7.66

FROM OUR FRYER

  • French Fries

    Super - $3.50... Large - $2.49... Small - $1.99
  • Cajun Spicy Fries

    Super - $4.20... Large - $2.69... Small - $2.19
  • Sweet Potato Fries

    Served with our brown sugar & cinnamon butter for dipping.

    Super - $5.84... Large - $3.27... Small - $2.80
  • Onion Rings

    Super - $4.90... Large - $2.95... Small - $2.49
  • Breaded Zucchini Sticks

    Served with ranch for dipping.

    Super - $6.08... Large - $3.50... Small - $3.04
  • Breaded Mushrooms

    Very tasty, you’ll love em. Choice of ranch or our horsey sauce for dipping.

    Super - $6.77... Large - $4.20... Small - $3.73
  • Corn Nuggets

    You gotta try these with powdered sugar.

    (12) - $6.77... (9) - $4.20... (6) - $3.73
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Served with our marinara sauce.

    (12) - $7.47... (9) - $5.84... (6) - $3.97
  • Wild Jalapeno Poppers

    Breaded green jalapeño peppers stuffed with cream cheese. Served with a super raspberry sauce. (Extra Raspberry Sauce $ .50)

    Super - $8.97... Large - $6.30... Small - $4.90
  • Breaded Pickle Slices

    Served with ranch dressing to dip.

    Super - $6.77 Large - $4.20 Small - $3.73
  • Triple Play

    Any three items from fryer menu except chicken wings

    $8.36
  • Chicken Finger Basket

    Served with French Fries

    (4pc) - $6.54 (3pc) - $5.60 (2pc) - $4.67
  • Jumbo Shrimp Basket

    Served with French Fries

    $8.79
  • Potato Skins

    Bacon-Cheddar

    (6) - $5.99... (4) - $4.99
  • Buffalo Chicken Wings

    Served with blue cheese, carrots & celery sticks. Choose Mild, Medium, Hot or BBQ

    (15) - $11.99... (10) - $8.99

SANDWICHES

  • Hamburger

    1/4 lb. beef patty topped with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, mustard, ketchup and pickles.

    $3.64
  • Cheese Burger

    Add bacon...$0.50 Add grilled mushrooms...$0.35

    $3.97
  • Double Cheese Burger

    $5.60
  • Triple Cheese Burger

    $6.77
  • Bimbo Burger

    1/4 lb. beef patty, topped with american cheese, grilled ham and any of the toppings.

    $4.20
  • Mini Sub Sandwiches

    Any cold sub on a burger bun. (Excluding All American, Lilly’s Combo & Ultimate)

    $3.27
  • Chicken Breast

    Grilled tender breast of chicken with lettuce, tomato & mayo.

    $3.99
  • Country Fried Steak

    Served on a Kaiser Roll with lettuce, tomato and onion.

    $5.99
  • Fish Sandwhich

    A perfect portion of fresh Pollock

    $3.99

SALADS

Each of our salads come with your choice of: Ranch, Buffalo ranch, 1000 Island, Honey Mustard, French, Oil & Vinegar, Italian, Creamy Italian or Bleu Cheese Dressing.

  • Garden Salad

    “8” That’s right - eight healthy veggies piled high. Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, celery, bell peppers, cucumbers, carrots and black olives. Served with crackers. ADD Grilled Chicken Breast for only a $1.99...

    $5.56
  • Tuna Salad

    All the goodies from the garden salad plus 2 big scoops of our fresh tuna. It’s yummy and good for you as well!

    $6.16
  • Chef Salad

    Everything from the garden salad plus a nice portion of imported ham, oven roasted white turkey, hard boiled egg and provolone cheese. It’s a real tasty and healthy meal!

    $6.49

SIDE ORDERS

  • Chips

    $0.51
  • Deviled Eggs

    $1.86
  • Brownie

    $1.85
  • Cheese Cake Slice

    Slice - $2.79

PARTY TRAYS

  • Small

    Feeds approximately 12 to 15 people

    Sub - $46.95
  • Large

    Feeds approximately 16 to 20 people

    Sub - $59.95
  • Super

    Feeds approximately 24 to 30 people.

    Sub - $89.95

Need More? Ask About Our “FULL PACKAGE TRAY

EXTRAS

  • Extra 2oz Dressing

    $0.25
  • Extra Bacon

    (3) - $0.85 (2) - $0.50
  • Double Cheese

    LG. - .50... SM. - .35
  • Extra Meat

    LG. - .85 SM. - .50
  • Peppers On The Side

    $0.25
  • Grilled Mushrooms

    LG. - .50 SM. - .35

DRINKS

  • Your Choice of

    Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Lemonade, Root Beer or Mr. Pibb

    SM. - $1.63... MED. - $1.86... LG. - $2.10...
  • Fresh Brewed Ice Tea

    Sweet or Un-sweet

    SM. - $1.63 MED. - $1.86 LG. - $2.10
  • Cold Draft and Bottled Beer

    Frosty Pint... $3.00 Frosty Super Mug... $4.00 Pitcher... $8.00 Bottle Beers... $3.00

  • Wine

    Red or White By The Glass

    3.50